Interpret a Result Where There Is No Zone of Inhibition

Learning Objectives

• Trace how the Kirby-Bauer disk diffusion test determines the susceptibleness of a microbe to an antibacterial drug.
• Explicate the significance of the minimal inhibitory denseness and the borderline disinfectant concentration relative to the effectiveness of an antimicrobial do drugs.

Examination the effectiveness of antimicrobial drugs against specific organisms is important in characteristic their spectrum of action and the therapeutic dose. This type of test, generally represented as antimicrobial susceptibility examination (AST), is commonly performed in a clinical lab. Therein department, we will discuss grassroots methods of testing the effectiveness of antimicrobials.

The Kirby-Bauer Magnetic disk Diffusion Test

The Kirby-Bauer disk diffusion test has hourlong been used as a starting steer for determining the susceptibility of specific microbes to single antimicrobial drugs. The Kirby-Bauer assay starts with a Mueller-Hinton nutrient agar plate on which a affluent lawn is inoculated with a patient's isolated bacterial pathogen. Filter paper disks impregnated with noted amounts of bactericide drugs to be tested are then placed on the nutrient agar plate. Eastern Samoa the bacterial inoculant grows, antibiotic diffuses from the circular disk into the agar and interacts with the growing bacteria. Bactericide activity is observed as a clear circular zone of inhibition around the drug-impregnated disc, similar to the disk-dispersion assay depicted in Figure 1 in Testing the Effectiveness of Antiseptics and Disinfectants. The diameter of the zone of inhibition, measured in millimeters and compared to a standardized chart, determines the susceptibility or resistance of the microorganism pathogen to the do drugs.

At that place are multiple factors that regulate the size of a geographical zone of inhibition therein seek, including do drugs solvability, rate of drug diffusion through agar, the thickness of the agar average, and the dose concentration impregnated into the platter. Due to a lack of standardization of these factors, interpretation of the Kirby-Bauer disk diffusion try provides only limited information on susceptibleness and resistance to the drugs tested. The assay cannot distinguish between bacteriostatic and bactericidal activities, and differences in partition sizes cannot be accustomed compare do drugs potencies or efficacies. Comparison of zone sizes to a standardized chart will alone bring home the bacon information happening the antibacterials to which a microorganism pathogen is suasible or resistant.

Think about Information technology

• How does one use of goods and services the information from a Kirby-Bauer assay to predict the therapeutic effectiveness of an antimicrobial drug in a patient?

Antibiograms: Winning Some of the Guesswork Out of Prescriptions

Unfortunately, infectious diseases don't take a time-out for lab work. As a result, physicians rarely experience the lavishness of conducting susceptibility examination before they compose a prescription. Instead, they rely primarily on the data-based evidence (i.e., the signs and symptoms of disease) and their professional undergo to make an knowledgeable guess as to the diagnosing, contributive agent(s), and do drugs most credible to be effective. This approach allows treatment to begin sooner and so the patient does not take over to wait for lab test results. In many a cases, the prescription is effective; notwithstandin, in an age of increased antimicrobial resistivity, it is becoming increasingly to a greater extent rough to select the most appropriate empiric therapy. Selecting an unfitting falsifiable therapy not lone puts the patient at gamble simply may promote greater resistance to the drug positive.

Late, studies have shown that antibiograms are useful tools in the decision-making process of selecting harmonious a posteriori therapy. An antibiogram is a compilation of local antibiotic susceptibleness data broken down by bacterial pathogen. In a November 2014 discipline published in the journal Infection Control and Hospital Epidemiology, researchers determined that 85% of the prescriptions arranged in delicate nursing facilities were distinct upon empirically, but only 35% of those prescriptions were deemed appropriate when compared with the eventual pathogen identification and susceptibleness profile obtained from the medical institution laboratory. Notwithstandin, in one breast feeding installation where habituate of antibiograms was enforced to direct selection of empiric therapy, appropriateness of empiric therapy increased from 32% before antibiogram implementation to 45% after implementation of antibiograms.^[1] Although these data are preliminary, they make out suggest that health-care facilities can trim down the number of inappropriate prescriptions by using antibiograms to quality empiric therapy, thus benefiting patients and minimizing opportunities for antimicrobial opposition to develop.

Dilution Tests

Figure 1. In a dilution test, the lowest dilution that inhibits turbidness (cloudiness) is the MIC. In this good example, the MIC is 8 μg/mL. Stock from samples without turbidness dismiss be inoculated onto plates lacking the antimicrobial dose. The lowest dilution that kills ≥99.9% of the starting inoculant is observed on the plates is the MBC. (credit: modification of play by Suzanne Wakim)

As discussed, the limitations of the Kirby-Bauer disk diffusion test exercise not allow for a direct comparison of antibacterial potencies to conduct selection of the best therapeutic choice. All the same, antibacterial dilution tests can be used to determine a particular drug's minimal inhibitory concentration (MIC), the last concentration of drug that inhibits visible bacterial increase, and tokenish disinfectant concentration (MBC), the lowest drug concentration that kills ≥99.9% of the starting inoculant. Determining these concentrations helps identify the correct drug for a uncommon pathogen. For the macrobroth dilution try out, a dilution series of the dose in broth is made in test tubes and the same number of cells of a quiz bacterial strain is added to each tube (Figure 1). The MIC is determined by examining the tubes to find the lowest drug assiduity that inhibits visible growth; this is discovered as turbidness (cloudiness) in the broth. Tubes with no visible increase are then inoculated onto agar media without bactericide to determine the MBC. Broadly, serum levels of an antibacterial should equal at least three to five times above the MIC for treatment of an infection.

The MIC assay can also be performed using 96-well microdilution trays, which allow for the use of small volumes and automated dispensing devices, as comfortably equally the testing of quadruplicate antimicrobials and/or microorganisms in one tray (Image 2). MICs are taken As the lowest concentration that inhibits visible ontogenesis, the same American Samoa for the macrobroth dilution in test tubes. Emergence may also be interpreted visually or by victimisation a spectrophotometer operating theater similar device to detect turbidity OR a color change if an appropriate organic chemistry substrate that changes color in the presence of microorganism growth is too included in each well.

Figure 2. A microdilution tray can too glucinium used to regulate MICs of quadruple antimicrobial drugs in a single essay. In this instance, the do drugs concentrations increase from left to right and the rows with clindamycin, penicillin, and erythromycin have been indicated to the left-wing of the home plate. For penicillin and Ilosone, the worst concentrations that strangled visible growth are indicated past red circles and were 0.06 μg/mL for penicillin and 8 μg/milliliter for Pediamycin. For clindamycin, visible bacterial growth was observed at every engrossment upbound to 32 μg/mL and the MIC is taken as >32 μg/mL. (credit: limiting of work by Centers for Disease Control and Bar)

The Etest is an alternative method wont to ascertain MIC, and is a combination of the Kirby-Bauer disk diffusion test and dilution methods. Alike to the Kirby-Bauer assay, a feeder lawn of a bacterial isolate is inoculated onto the surface of an agar shell. Rather than exploitation globular disks impregnated with one concentration of dose, however, commercially available moldable strips that hold a gradient of an antibacterial drug are placed on the rise of the inoculated agar plate (Figure 3). As the bacterial inoculum grows, antibiotic diffuses from the plastic strips into the nutrient agar and interacts with the microorganism cells. Because the plac of drug diffusion is directly attendant concentration, an egg-shaped zone of inhibition is observed with the Etest drug slope, rather than a circular zone of inhibition discovered with the Kirby-Bauer assay. To interpret the results, the intersection of the elliptical zone with the gradient on the drug-containing strip indicates the MIC. Because multiple strips containing disparate antimicrobials behind make up placed on the same dental plate, the MIC of multiple antimicrobials can be ascertained concurrently and at once compared. However, unlike the macrobroth and microbroth dilution methods, the MBC cannot be determined with the Etest.

Figure 3. The Etest dismiss be used to determine the MIC of an antibiotic. In this Etest, Vancocin is shown to have a MIC of 1.5 μg/mL against Staphylococci aureus.

Think some IT

• Compare and contrast MIC and MBC.

Clinical Focus: Nakry, Resolution

This example concludes Nakry's story that started in History of Chemotherapy and Antimicrobial Discovery, Mechanisms of Bactericide Drugs, and Drug Resistance.

Nakry's UTI was likely caused by the catheterizations she had in Vietnam. About bacteria that drive UTIs are members of the normal catgut microbiota, but they throne campaign infections when introduced to the body waste tract, as might possess occurred when the catheter was inserted. Alternatively, if the catheter itself was not unproductive, bacterium on its open could have been introduced into Nakry's body. The disinfectant therapy Nakry received in Cambodia may also have been a complicating factor out because information technology may have selected for antimicrobial-resistant strains already pose in her consistence. These bacterium would have already contained genes for antimicrobial resistance, either acquired by spontaneous mutation or through horizontal gene transfer, and, therefore, had the best evolutionary reward for adaptation and growth in the presence of the antimicrobial therapy. As a result, one of these nonabsorptive strains English hawthorn have been subsequently introduced into her urinary tract.

Laboratory testing at the CDC confirmed that the strain of Klebsiella pneumoniae from Nakry's urine sample was positive for the presence of NDM, a selfsame active carbapenemase that is beginning to emerge as a new trouble in disinfectant resistance. Spell NDM-positive strains are resistant to a wide order of antimicrobials, they have shown susceptibility to tigecycline (structurally incidental tetracycline) and the polymyxins B and E (colistin).

To forestall her contagion from spreading, Nakry was isolated from the other patients in a separate room. All hospital faculty interacting with her were considered to follow strict protocols to prevent aerofoil and equipment contamination. This would include especially stringent hand hygiene practices and careful disinfection of all items coming into contact with her.

Nakry's infection finally responded to tigecycline and eventually cleared. She was discharged a few weeks after admission fee, and a stick with-up can sample showed her stool to exist gratuitous of NDM-containing K. pneumoniae, meaning that she was zero longer harboring the extremely resistant bacterium.

Key Concepts and Summary

• The Kirby-Bauer disk diffusion test helps determine the susceptibility of a microorganism to various antimicrobial drugs. Yet, the zones of inhibition plumbed must embody related to known standards to see susceptibility and resistance, and do not provide information on bactericidal versus bacteriostatic activity, or provide for maneuver comparison of drug potencies.
• Antibiograms are useful for monitoring local trends in antimicrobial resistance/susceptibility and for directing appropriate selection of empiric antibacterial therapy.
• There are single laboratory methods getable for determinant the minimum repressing assiduity (MIC) of an germicide drug against a peculiar bug. The minimal bactericidal concentration (MBC) can also be stubborn, typically as a follow-up experiment to MIC determination using the tube dilution method.

Multiple Choice

In the Kirby-Bauer disk dispersal test, the _______ of the zone of inhibition is rhythmical and used for interpretation.

1. diameter
2. microbial population
3. circumference
4. profoundness

Usher Answer

Answer a. In the Kirby-Bauer disk diffusion test, the diameter of the zone of inhibition is measured and used for rendering.

Which of the following techniques cannot be used to determine the minimum repressing concentration of an antimicrobial do drugs against a particular microbe?

1. Etest
2. microbroth dilution test
3. Kirby-Bauer disk diffusion tryout
4. macrobroth dilution trial

Show Answer

Answer c. The Kirby-Bauer disk diffusion test cannot be ill-used to determine the token inhibitory concentration of an healthful drug against a particular microbe.

The utility of an antibiogram is that it shows healthful susceptibility trends

1. over a sizeable geographic area.
2. for an individual unhurried.
3. in research laboratory strains.
4. in a localized population.

Show Serve

Answer d. The utility of an antibiogram is that it shows antimicrobial susceptibility trends in a localized population.

Fill in the Blank

The method acting that can determine the MICs of two-fold antimicrobial drugs against a micro-organism strain using a single agar plate is called the ________.

Show Answer

The method that can find out the MICs of seven-fold antimicrobial drugs against a microbial strain using a single agar home base is called the Etest.

True/False

If dose A produces a larger zone of inhibition than do drugs B on the Kirby-Bauer magnetic disk diffusion examine, dose A should always embody prescribed.

Think about It

1. How is the information from a Kirby-Bauer disk diffusion test used for the testimonial of the clinical use of an antimicrobial drug?
2. What is the difference between MIC and MBC?
3. Can an Etest be wont to witness the MBC of a drug? Explain.

---

Interpret a Result Where There Is No Zone of Inhibition

Source: https://courses.lumenlearning.com/microbiology/chapter/testing-the-effectiveness-of-antimicrobials/

Share this post